Blog

Here you’ll find everything you need to learn about digital software technology, development trends and beyond

Categories

Herd Behaviour and Market Bubbles: How Individual Decisions Become Collective Risk

Herd Behaviour and Market Bubbles: How Individual Decisions Become Collective Risk

Every investor has felt it. A stock rises for five days in a row. Your friends talk about it, your colleague has bought it, and a stranger on social media says it will double. You do not know much about the company, but sitting out feels worse than getting in. So you buy.

That is herd behaviour in the stock market, and it is one of the main reasons market bubbles form. In this article, we explain what herd behaviour is, why it happens, how it turns private decisions into shared risk, and what you can do to stay safe. The examples are drawn from both global and Indian markets, so you can see the same pattern repeat across decades.

What Is Herd Behaviour in the Stock Market?

Herd behaviour, also called herd mentality, is the tendency of investors to follow what the majority is doing instead of relying on their own research and analysis. When many people buy, an individual feels pressure to buy. When many people sell, the same individual feels pressure to sell.

In behavioural finance, this is treated as a bias, not a flaw of intelligence. Smart, well-informed people fall for it too. The reason is simple. Following the crowd feels safe. If you lose money along with everyone else, the loss feels easier to explain.

Herd behaviour is not always irrational. If a thousand people have studied a company and chosen to buy, their combined view carries some information. The trouble starts when people copy each other without doing any study of their own. At that point, the price no longer reflects the value of the business. It reflects only the mood of the crowd.

Why Do Investors Follow the Crowd?

There are several well-known reasons, and most of them work together.

1. Fear of missing out (FOMO). Watching others make quick profits is painful. FOMO in investing pushes people to buy near the top, just when the risk is highest.

2. Social proof. In the 1950s, psychologist Solomon Asch showed that people often give a wrong answer just to agree with a group. Markets work the same way. If everyone around you is buying, buying seems correct.

3. Information shortage. Most retail investors cannot study balance sheets, management quality and industry trends for every stock. It is easier to assume that others know something you do not.

4. Fear of regret. An investor who goes against the crowd and is wrong feels foolish. An investor who goes with the crowd and is wrong feels unlucky. Most people prefer to feel unlucky.

5. Recent success (recency bias). If markets have gone up for two years, many investors assume they will keep going up. They forget that long rallies end.

6. Social media and WhatsApp groups. Tips now travel in seconds. A single post can send thousands of small investors into the same stock on the same day, often without any real research behind it.

How Individual Decisions Become Collective Risk

This is the central question, and the answer lies in how many small choices add up to a large problem.

One investor buying a stock on a tip is a small, personal risk. Ten lakh investors doing the same thing is a market-wide risk. Here is how the shift takes place.

Step one: Prices rise because of buying, not because of value. When many people buy at once, the price goes up. The higher price then attracts attention, and attention brings in more buyers. This loop is called a feedback loop.

Step two: Rising prices look like proof. New investors see the chart going up and take it as a sign the stock is good. They do not ask whether the business has grown to match the price.

Step three: Borrowed money enters. As confidence grows, people use margin funding, personal loans and credit cards to invest more. Leverage makes the rally stronger on the way up and far more painful on the way down.

Step four: Everyone holds the same bets. When most investors own the same stocks, funds and sectors, the market loses its balance. A fall in one place spreads quickly to others.

Step five: The first sellers trigger panic. Once prices slip, margin calls begin and fear spreads. Everyone rushes to sell at once, and there are no buyers left. Prices fall faster than they rose.

This is why one person’s decision to follow the crowd is never only their own problem. Together, such decisions build a fragile market that can break from a small shock.

What Is a Market Bubble?

A market bubble forms when the price of an asset rises far above its real or fundamental value, mainly because of crowd excitement. The bubble ends when prices fall back sharply, often called a bubble burst or a stock market crash.

Economist Hyman Minsky described a common pattern with five stages:

  1. Displacement: A new idea, technology or policy change catches attention.
  2. Boom: Prices rise steadily and more investors join.
  3. Euphoria: Caution disappears. People believe prices will keep rising, and valuations stop mattering.
  4. Profit-taking: Early and experienced investors quietly start selling.
  5. Panic: Prices drop, fear takes over, and selling becomes widespread.

If you read about any bubble in history, you will find all five stages in the same order.

Famous Examples of Herd Behaviour and Market Bubbles

Tulip Mania (Netherlands, 1630s)

In the 1630s, the price of tulip bulbs in the Dutch Republic rose to extreme levels before collapsing. Historians still debate how large the damage was, but the episode is often used as the first well-known example of speculative excess.

The Dot-Com Bubble (1995 to 2002)

Investors rushed into internet companies, many of which had no profits and sometimes no clear business plan. The Nasdaq index peaked in March 2000 and then fell by close to 78 per cent by October 2002. Many people who bought only because “the internet is the future” lost a large share of their savings.

The 2008 Global Financial Crisis

A long rise in US housing prices led banks and investors to believe that property prices could never fall. Risky home loans were packed into complex products and sold widely. When prices turned, the losses spread across the global financial system.

The Harshad Mehta Scam (India, 1992)

In India, the 1992 securities scam showed how quickly the market could rise on borrowed money and crowd enthusiasm. Stock prices shot up, retail investors piled in, and the collapse that followed wiped out wealth for many families.

The Ketan Parekh Era and the Tech Bubble (India, 1999 to 2001)

Indian markets also joined the global technology rush. Stocks linked to information technology, media and telecom rose sharply, and many fell steeply once the bubble burst in 2001.

Small-Cap and IPO Frenzy (India, 2021 to 2024)

After 2020, demat account openings in India grew at a record pace, crossing 15 crore by 2024. A large part of this new money went into small-cap stocks, new-age company IPOs and short-term trading. SEBI’s own studies on equity futures and options trading found that roughly nine out of ten individual traders lost money over a multi-year period. This is a clear case of individual decisions turning into collective risk.

Meme Stocks and Crypto Rallies

The GameStop surge of January 2021 was driven largely by posts on online forums. Cryptocurrency rallies have followed the same story more than once: a sharp rise, heavy social media talk, and then a steep fall.

Warning Signs of a Market Bubble

No one can time a bubble exactly, but certain signs appear again and again:

  • Prices rising much faster than company earnings
  • Very high price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios across the market, with the argument that “this time is different”
  • A rush of new IPOs, many of them priced aggressively
  • Friends, relatives and taxi drivers giving stock tips
  • Heavy use of leverage and margin funding
  • Stock market apps and financial influencers showing guaranteed or “sure-shot” returns
  • Loss-making companies seeing large price gains

If several of these appear at the same time, it is a good moment to slow down and review your portfolio.

How to Avoid Herd Mentality in Investing

The good news is that herd behaviour can be managed with some simple habits.

1. Build an investment plan before you invest. Decide your goals, time period and risk level in writing. When the market gets noisy, your plan is your anchor.

2. Do your own research. Before buying any stock, read the annual report, check the debt level, understand how the company earns money, and compare the valuation with peers.

3. Use asset allocation. Spread your money across equity, debt, gold and cash according to your needs. A balanced portfolio is less likely to suffer a severe loss when one asset class falls.

4. Invest through SIPs. A Systematic Investment Plan spreads your buying across market ups and downs. It removes the pressure of deciding when to enter, and it helps you avoid putting a large amount into the market at a peak.

5. Rebalance on schedule. Once or twice a year, bring your portfolio back to your target allocation. This forces you to sell some of what has risen and buy some of what has fallen, which is the opposite of what the crowd does.

6. Avoid leverage. Borrowing to invest makes a bad decision much worse. Never invest money that you may need in the next few years.

7. Limit your exposure to tips. Be careful with unsolicited advice on social media and messaging groups. Check whether the person giving the tip is a SEBI-registered investment adviser or research analyst.

8. Keep a decision journal. Write down why you bought each stock. When you review it later, you will see which decisions came from research and which came from excitement.

9. Think long term. Daily price changes are mostly noise. Over many years, share prices follow business earnings. Investors who hold quality businesses through cycles tend to do better than those who keep chasing the latest trend.

Can Herd Behaviour Ever Be Useful?

Sometimes. Following broad market trends through low-cost index funds, for example, is a kind of crowd participation that works well over long periods. The difference is that you are buying the whole market at a regular pace, not putting all your money into the single stock that everyone is talking about.

Legendary investor Warren Buffett’s advice sums up the contrarian approach well: be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful. This does not mean doing the opposite of the crowd every time. It means thinking independently and acting on value.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is herd behaviour in the stock market?

Herd behaviour in the stock market is when investors copy the actions of others, buying or selling because the crowd is doing so, instead of making decisions based on their own analysis.

What causes a market bubble?

A market bubble is caused by a mix of easy money, new stories about growth, rising prices that attract more buyers, and crowd excitement. Prices rise well above real value until confidence breaks.

How does herd behaviour lead to a stock market crash?

When many investors hold the same stocks, often with borrowed money, a small fall in prices can cause forced selling. Others then sell out of fear, and the fall becomes a crash.

Is herd behaviour common among Indian retail investors?

Yes. Studies and market events over the years show that new investors in India often chase recent winners, such as hot IPOs, small-cap stocks and tips shared on social media. This is common in every market, not only India.

How can I protect myself from a market bubble?

Use a written plan, invest through SIPs, diversify across asset classes, avoid leverage, do your own research, and rebalance regularly.

Is it a good time to invest when everyone is buying?

Not always. When buying is widespread and valuations are high, future returns tend to be lower and risks higher. Check valuations and your own goals before you invest.

Conclusion

Herd behaviour is part of human nature. We are social creatures, and we find comfort in agreement. But in the stock market, comfort is often costly. Every bubble in history, from tulips to dot-coms to modern small-cap rallies, began with ordinary people making what felt like reasonable decisions. Added together, those decisions created a risk that none of them had planned for.

You cannot control the crowd, but you can control your own response to it. Make a plan, understand what you own, stay diversified, and keep your decisions based on facts and not on noise. Over time, that discipline matters far more than catching the next big rally.

Be Part of Something Bigger!
Whether you’re exploring new ideas, learning something new, or looking for opportunities, Enigma Community brings you closer to a world of possibilities.
Join Us: https://www.enigmacommunity.com/

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks. Please read all scheme-related documents carefully and consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making any investment decision.